Key facts
- Zillow has filed a motion to dismiss the Taylor-Armstrong lawsuit with prejudice.
- The lawsuit alleges Zillow violated RESPA and the Washington Consumer Protection Act.
- Plaintiffs claim Zillow required agents to steer homebuyers to Zillow Home Loans for leads.
- Zillow argues mortgage preapproval letters are not settlement services under RESPA.
- The company also claims a cooperative brokerage safe harbor would protect it.
- Judge James Robart previously dismissed the lawsuit but allowed plaintiffs to amend their complaint.
Zillow is seeking to have the Real Estate Settlement Procedures Act (RESPA) claims against it in the combined Taylor-Armstrong lawsuit dismissed with prejudice, which would prevent the plaintiffs from refiling their case. The company filed its motion on Tuesday, arguing that the plaintiffs have failed to correct the deficiencies previously identified by Judge James Robart of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington.
In its filing, Zillow contends that the plaintiffs have not alleged sufficient facts to support their RESPA or Washington Consumer Protection Act (WCPA) claims, despite opportunities to amend their complaint. Zillow stated that the plaintiffs continue to assert the same claims tied to pre-approval letters and performance metrics that the court previously found insufficient.
The lawsuit, which was reopened in August, alleges that Zillow's Preferred and Flex programs required participating agents to steer homebuyers toward Zillow Home Loans in exchange for buyer leads. The plaintiffs claim this undisclosed arrangement violated RESPA by providing agents with leads for mortgage referrals and limiting consumer choice. Zillow counters that a mortgage preapproval letter is not a settlement service under RESPA and that encouraging a free preapproval does not constitute a referral under the statute.
Furthermore, Zillow argues that even if a RESPA violation occurred, a cooperative brokerage safe harbor would protect the company, as Zillow and participating brokerages operate through referral arrangements with clear disclosures. Zillow also highlighted in a blog post that consumers were not required to use Zillow Home Loans and did not pay for pre-approvals, with some even negotiating fees, demonstrating consumer choice.
