Key facts
- Israel does not have the legal right to close the British consulate in East Jerusalem, according to legal advice received by the UK Foreign Office.
- Israel's Foreign Minister Gideon Saar announced the closure of the consulate as a retaliatory measure for the UK's ban on trade with Israeli settlements.
- Dominic Grieve KC, former UK Attorney General, opined that Israel's threat to close the consulate is illegal and an unlawful assertion of sovereignty over occupied Palestinian territory.
- The British mission in East Jerusalem conducts relations with Palestinians and its status is linked to the unresolved final status of Jerusalem.
- Grieve noted that British consul generals do not present commissions to Israel, meaning there is no accreditation for Israel to withdraw.
- The closure of the consulate would impact consular services for British pilgrims, visitors, and residents of Palestine, and hamper aid oversight in the West Bank and Gaza.
The UK Foreign Office has received legal advice indicating that Israel does not possess the legal right to close the British Consulate in East Jerusalem. The consulate, located in the Sheikh Jarrah neighborhood, remains open for business despite an ultimatum from Israeli Foreign Minister Gideon Saar to shut it down by October 8.
Saar's announcement of the closure was framed as a retaliatory measure following UK Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband's decision to ban trade with Israeli settlements. However, Middle East Eye has revealed that Britain is considering defying this ultimatum, although a final decision has not yet been made.
Dominic Grieve KC, a former UK Attorney General, provided a legal opinion stating that Israel's threat to close the consulate is illegal and constitutes an "unlawful assertion of sovereignty over occupied Palestinian territory." He argued that Israel, as an occupying power, does not have the right to impose sovereign control over East Jerusalem. Grieve also noted that the British mission's commission is not accredited to Israel, meaning Israel has no authority to withdraw it.
The British Consulate in East Jerusalem has a long history, established in 1838, predating the state of Israel. It serves as the UK's diplomatic mission to the Palestinians and its status is linked to the unresolved final status of Jerusalem. Grieve warned that closing the consulate would negatively impact consular services for British citizens and residents of Palestine, and hinder aid oversight.
