All NewsEducationTV
Equities & FundsCrypto & Digital AssetsAI & TechnologyBusiness & CorporateUS Politics & PolicyGeopolitics & Global RiskMacro, Rates & FXCommodities & EnergyEuropean Politics & MarketsAsia-PacificReal Estate & Property
All NewsHome
← Back to Commodities & Energy

Rare Earths Push Beyond China Raises Environmental Cost Questions

Created at 22 Aug · 1:06 AM1 source↑ Market-relevant
IN SHORT

As Australia and Brazil seek to diversify rare earth supplies away from China, the environmental impact of extraction and refining becomes a critical concern. Buyers face questions about sharing the costs of cleaner production, while Indigenous communities in Brazil raise alarms about potential risks near the Amazon.

Key Numbers

42%rare earth exploration applications in Brazil by foreign-owned firms
86%rare earth exploration applications in Brazil filed in the past three years
2022year of International Energy Agency estimate on rare earth demand
2040year by which rare earth demand could at least triple

Who's Involved

Australia
seeking to become a responsible supplier of rare earths
Brazil
emerging as an alternative to China's rare earth dominance
United States
investing in Brazil's rare earth sector
China
dominant supplier of rare earths
Indigenous communities in Brazil
raising alarms about environmental risks of rare earth mining
Robert Muggah
co-founder of the Igarape Institute, commenting on Brazil's rare earths significance
Rare Earths Push Beyond China Raises Environmental Cost Questions

↳ Why This Matters

The global push to secure rare earth supplies outside of China highlights a critical tension between the demand for these essential minerals for green technologies and the significant environmental costs of their extraction and processing, potentially impacting sensitive ecosystems and local communities.

Key facts

  • Australia is seeking to become a responsible supplier of rare earths, offering an alternative to China's market dominance.
  • Brazil is emerging as a key player in rare earth reserves and exploration, attracting substantial foreign investment, particularly from the U.S. and Australia.
  • A significant portion of rare earth exploration applications in Brazil are from foreign-owned companies, with mining potentially impacting the Amazon rainforest.
  • Indigenous communities in Brazil are raising concerns about the environmental risks associated with increased rare earth mining.
  • Demand for rare earths is expected to at least triple by 2040 due to their essential role in green technologies and electronics.

As Australia seeks to establish itself as a responsible alternative supplier of rare earths, the question of who will bear the environmental costs associated with minimizing the industry's significant impact remains unresolved. Simultaneously, Brazil is emerging as a crucial player in the global race for these critical minerals, attracting substantial foreign investment, particularly from the United States and Australia. This surge in exploration, with over 86% of applications filed in the last three years, is driven by the need for supply chain diversification away from China's dominance. However, this expansion, which includes areas near the Amazon rainforest, raises serious environmental concerns, particularly for Indigenous communities who are beginning to voice their alarms. The U.S. government has also shown interest, with a stake in a firm that acquired Brazil's sole commercial rare earth producer. The demand for rare earths is projected to increase significantly by 2040, underscoring the urgency of addressing both supply security and environmental sustainability in their extraction and processing.

Frequently asked questions

Rare earths are essential for digital and defense technologies, including electronics, magnets, batteries, wind turbines, and electric vehicle motors, crucial for the transition away from fossil fuels.

China is currently the dominant supplier, but Australia and Brazil are emerging as significant alternatives, attracting foreign investment for exploration and production.

Rare earth extraction and refining can involve significant environmental impacts, including wastewater discharge and potential risks to ecosystems like the Amazon rainforest.

What Happens Next

01Buyers will face questions about sharing the costs of minimizing the environmental impact of rare earth production.
02Further analysis of mining permits in Brazil will continue to track foreign investment and potential environmental risks.
CME Headlines
  • Gold futures hit May highs as fiscal concerns offset yields.
    21 Aug · 9:05 PM
  • Gold futures hit May highs as fiscal concerns offset yields.
    21 Aug · 9:05 PM
  • RBOB Gasoline futures reach highest levels since June as volume rolls.
    21 Aug · 8:29 PM

How It Developed

Australia aims to be a responsible supplier of rare earths as an alternative to China.
Brazil is emerging as a significant alternative to China's rare earth dominance, attracting foreign investment.
Rare earth exploration applications in Brazil have surged, with a significant portion by foreign-owned companies.
Mining in Brazil, potentially near the Amazon rainforest, carries major environmental risks and concerns from Indigenous communities.
China's past restrictions on rare earth exports have pressured Western companies and influenced supply-chain diversification efforts.
The U.S. government has a stake in a firm that purchased Brazil's only commercial rare earth producer.
Demand for rare earths is projected to increase significantly by 2040 due to their use in green technologies and electronics.

Sources

T1
Who bears environmental cost of push for rare earths beyond China?Nikkei Asia
T2
Brazil draws US and other investment in rare earths as China sets ...apnews.com
T2
Southeast Asia is paying the environmental price of the rare earth boomlowyinstitute.org
T2
Rare earth supply chains: Funding, policy and China's edgespglobal.com

Related Stories

Australia urged to remain realistic in critical minerals race
21 Aug · 1:10 PM
China solar farms may be harming bird populations, study finds
21 Aug · 3:05 AM
Australia's Beetaloo Shale Basin Set to Begin Gas Production Next Month
21 Aug · 7:36 AM
China Oil Imports May Rise in Q4, but Reserves Buffer Market Shocks
21 Aug · 8:16 AM
Iranian oil prices climb as US blockade squeezes China's supply
21 Aug · 11:16 AM