Key facts
- Justice Samuel Alito will not participate in a Supreme Court case concerning oil companies' climate change liability.
- Alito owns stock in seven energy and natural resources companies, including Phillips 66.
- The case involves Exxon Mobil and Suncor Energy, companies in which Alito does not directly hold stock.
- Watchdog groups have requested a Senate Judiciary Committee investigation into Alito's recusal decision.
- The Supreme Court adopted a formal ethics code in 2023.
Supreme Court Justice Samuel Alito recused himself Monday from a major climate-change case involving oil companies, citing stock holdings that could present a conflict of interest. The recusal comes shortly before the court hears a case filed by Boulder County, Colorado, against Suncor Energy and ExxonMobil, which alleges the companies deceived the public about the contribution of fossil fuels to climate change.
While Alito does not directly own stock in Suncor Energy or ExxonMobil, his financial disclosures show holdings in other energy companies, including Phillips 66, ConocoPhillips, and a Vanguard ETF with significant investments in Exxon Mobil. Watchdog groups, such as Consumer Watchdog, have argued that these holdings could indirectly benefit from a favorable decision in the case, potentially violating the court's recently adopted code of ethics. Alexandra Nagy, organizing director for Consumer Watchdog, stated that Alito's recusal was the right decision and should have been made earlier.
The Supreme Court adopted its first formal ethics code in 2023, which states that a justice should step aside if they or their families have a "subject matter or controversy" that could be affected by their participation. Critics, however, argue that the code is not enforceable. Senate Judiciary Committee ranking member Dick Durbin has indicated that the situation highlights the need for greater transparency and an enforceable code of conduct for justices.
The energy companies involved in the lawsuit argue that such climate litigation poses a significant threat to the industry and that state courts are not the appropriate venue for addressing global climate change issues. The Supreme Court agreed to hear an appeal from these companies in February.
