Israel withholding 1,700 Palestinian bodies for potential exchange deals
1 source↑ Market-relevant
IN SHORT
Israel is reportedly holding the bodies of approximately 1,700 Palestinians, a figure that has increased during recent high-level discussions. This policy, permitted under Israeli law but criticized by human rights groups and questioned by legal experts, is intended for potential future exchange deals, despite no current Israeli captives being held by Hamas.
✉Newsletter
PiQ Daily
Pick your topics. Get only what matters, on your cadence.
Key Numbers
1,700Palestinian bodies withheld by Israel
October 7, 2023date of attack on Israel
Who's Involved
Haaretz
Israeli daily newspaper reporting on the issue
Shin Bet
Israeli security agency supporting retention of bodies
Israeli army
Supports retaining bodies for future leverage
Adalah – The Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel
Filed petitions against the policy
Nareman Shehadeh-Zoabi
Adalah Attorney arguing against the policy
↳ Why This Matters
This policy raises significant ethical and legal concerns, highlighting the contentious issue of how bodies are handled in conflict zones and potentially exacerbating tensions between Israelis and Palestinians.
Key facts
Israel is withholding approximately 1,700 Palestinian bodies.
The policy is intended for potential future exchange deals.
The number of withheld bodies has increased recently.
Israeli legal experts question the authority to retain bodies without a clear policy.
The Israeli Supreme Court has upheld the policy.
International humanitarian law prohibits withholding bodies.
Israel is reportedly withholding the bodies of approximately 1,700 Palestinians for potential use in future exchange deals, according to Israeli newspaper Haaretz. This figure has reportedly increased during recent discussions among top Israeli leaders.
The policy, which is permitted under Israeli law, is supported by Shin Bet chief David Zini and the Israeli army, who believe the bodies can be used as leverage if Israelis are taken captive or go missing in the future. Haaretz indicated that most of the bodies belong to Palestinians from Gaza who participated in the October 7, 2023 attack or subsequent fighting, though some belong to individuals not involved in hostilities.
Legal experts cited by Haaretz have questioned Israel's authority to retain these bodies without a formal policy established by the Security Cabinet. Human rights groups have repeatedly condemned this practice, calling for the immediate return of the bodies to families. International humanitarian law explicitly prohibits the withholding of bodies, stipulating that the deceased must be treated with dignity and buried honorably.
The Israeli Supreme Court has upheld the policy, ruling that the Defense Minister has the authority under emergency regulations to withhold bodies for negotiation purposes. Adalah, a legal center, has argued that this decision validates Israel's treatment of deceased Palestinians as commodities for political and security objectives, causing profound harm to grieving families.
Frequently asked questions
Israel is reportedly withholding the bodies of approximately 1,700 Palestinians.
The bodies are being held for potential use in future exchange deals, as leverage in case Israelis are taken captive or go missing.
The policy is permitted under Israeli law, but legal experts question Israel's authority without a formal policy, and it is in conflict with international humanitarian law.
International humanitarian law explicitly prohibits withholding bodies, requiring them to be treated with dignity and buried honorably.
What Happens Next
01The Security Cabinet may establish an overarching policy on withholding Palestinian bodies.
02Further legal challenges to the policy may arise.
Get the newsletter.
Pick the topics you actually care about. We'll email when there's news worth your time, on the cadence you choose. Cancel any time from your account.
Cadence
How It Developed
Israel is withholding the bodies of about 1,700 Palestinians for potential use in future exchange deals.
The figure of held Palestinian bodies has increased during recent discussions among top Israeli leaders.
Shin Bet chief David Zini and the Israeli army support retaining bodies for potential future captures or disappearances.
Most retained bodies belong to Palestinians from Gaza involved in the October 7 attack or subsequent fighting.
Some bodies belong to Palestinians not involved in fighting.
Legal experts question Israel's authority to retain bodies without a clear policy established by the Security Cabinet.
The Israeli Supreme Court has upheld the policy of withholding bodies as bargaining chips.
The court ruled that the Defense Minister has authority under emergency regulations to withhold bodies for negotiations.
