HomeEverythingEducationTV
Equities & FundsCrypto & Digital AssetsAI & TechnologyBusiness & CorporateUS Politics & PolicyGeopolitics & Global RiskMacro, Rates & FXCommodities & EnergyEuropean Politics & MarketsAsia-PacificReal Estate & Property
Story archiveAll categories
← All Stories

Indonesia leads report on alleged abuses linked to China's critical minerals

Created at 21 Jul · 11:21 PM1 source↑ Market-relevant
IN SHORT

A report highlights a rise in alleged human rights and environmental abuses tied to China's critical minerals supply chains, with Indonesia recording the most incidents due to its nickel sector. Labor violations, including excessive hours and underpayment, have been documented at Chinese-invested smelters.

✉Newsletter

PiQ Daily

Pick your topics. Get only what matters, on your cadence.

Key Numbers

127allegations of abuse linked to transition mineral mining in Asia-Pacific (2010-2
45allegations recorded in Indonesia (2010-2024)
372hours of work in one documented month at PT Huadi Nickel Alloy Indonesia
240hours of work per month for some workers at PT Huadi Nickel Alloy Indonesia
$233monthly earnings for some workers at PT Huadi Nickel Alloy Indonesia
$244minimum wage in South Sulawesi for 2025

Who's Involved

LBH Makassar
Indonesian legal-aid organization that detailed labor violations
PT Huadi Nickel Alloy Indonesia
Chinese-invested nickel smelter accused of labor violations
Huadi Steel Group
Parent company of PT Huadi Nickel Alloy Indonesia
Business & Human Rights Resource Centre
Organization that released data on human rights risks in mining
Pochoy Labog
Southeast Asia Programme Manager at Business & Human Rights Resource Centre
Indonesia leads report on alleged abuses linked to China's critical minerals

↳ Why This Matters

The findings highlight significant human rights and labor concerns within the supply chains of critical minerals essential for the global energy transition, raising questions about responsible sourcing and the impact on local communities and workers.

Key facts

  • A report indicates a rise in alleged human rights and environmental abuses linked to China's critical minerals supply chains.
  • Indonesia has recorded the highest number of these allegations globally, primarily due to its nickel sector.
  • Serious labor violations, including excessive working hours and wages below the legal minimum, have been reported at a Chinese-invested nickel smelter in Indonesia.
  • The Business & Human Rights Resource Centre documented 127 allegations of abuse linked to transition mineral mining in Asia-Pacific between 2010 and 2024.
  • Local communities and workers are identified as the most impacted groups by these alleged abuses in the region.

Allegations of human rights and environmental abuses linked to China's critical minerals supply chains are increasing, with Indonesia experiencing more such incidents than any other country due to its expanding nickel sector, according to a recent report. The Business & Human Rights Resource Centre documented 127 allegations of abuse related to transition mineral mining in the Asia-Pacific region between 2010 and 2024, with Indonesia accounting for 45 of these.

Local communities and workers have been identified as the most affected groups by these alleged abuses. Specific concerns have been raised regarding PT Huadi Nickel Alloy Indonesia, a Chinese-invested nickel smelter, where workers have reportedly been subjected to excessive working hours, with some months reaching up to 372 hours, significantly exceeding Indonesia's legal limit. Wages for some employees have also allegedly fallen below the legal minimum.

Further accusations include forcing workers to clean dangerously hot furnaces and preventing Muslim employees from attending Friday Prayers. Indonesia's own Labor Inspectorate has confirmed that overtime pay was underpaid for 20 workers at the facility. The legal-aid organization LBH Makassar has formally submitted a case to Indonesia's National Commission on Human Rights, highlighting these issues.

The report underscores that while foreign embassies can be alerted, the responsibility for addressing these labor violations lies with Indonesian institutions, including the Labor Inspectorate, courts, and the Ministry of Manpower. The analysis also points out that the global rush for minerals essential for the energy transition is having a significant negative impact on workers, Indigenous Peoples, local communities, and human rights defenders in the Asia-Pacific region.

Frequently asked questions

The report highlights a rise in alleged human rights and environmental abuses linked to China's critical minerals supply chains, with Indonesia being the most affected country.

Nickel is the primary mineral linked to the alleged abuses in Indonesia, driven by its booming sector and demand for electric vehicle batteries and renewable energy technologies.

Reported violations include excessive working hours, wages below the legal minimum, forced cleaning of hot furnaces, and denial of religious services.

The responsibility for addressing these violations lies with Indonesian institutions, such as the Labor Inspectorate and the courts, rather than foreign embassies.

What Happens Next

01Indonesian authorities are expected to enforce labor laws at PT Huadi Nickel Alloy Indonesia.
02The Chinese Embassy in Jakarta may respond to the open letter from LBH Makassar.
03Further scrutiny is expected on the human rights impacts of critical mineral extraction in the Asia-Pacific region.

Get the newsletter.

Pick the topics you actually care about. We'll email when there's news worth your time, on the cadence you choose. Cancel any time from your account.

Cadence
CME Headlines
  • Soybean futures fell despite higher crop condition ratings.
    21 Jul · 8:30 PM
  • Soybean futures fell despite higher crop condition ratings.
    21 Jul · 8:30 PM
  • Feeder Cattle futures fell while lean hog futures advanced.
    21 Jul · 8:13 PM

How It Developed

A report indicates a rise in alleged human rights and environmental abuses linked to China's critical minerals supply chains.
Indonesia recorded the highest number of such allegations globally, attributed to its booming nickel sector.
A legal-aid organization detailed serious labor violations at PT Huadi Nickel Alloy Indonesia, a Chinese-invested nickel smelter.
Workers at the smelter reportedly face excessive hours and wages below the legal minimum.
Allegations include forced cleaning of hot furnaces and denial of religious services.
Indonesia's Labor Inspectorate confirmed underpaid overtime for some workers.
The Business & Human Rights Resource Centre documented 127 allegations of abuse linked to transition mineral mining in Asia-Pacific between 2010 and 2024.
Indonesia accounted for the highest number of allegations in Asia-Pacific, with local communities and workers being the most impacted.

Sources

T1
Indonesia tops report on alleged abuses linked to China critical mineralsNikkei Asia
T2
Notable human rights risks linked to mining of critical minerals in ...business-humanrights.org
T2
Indonesia: Workers, incl. Chinese migrants, protest at nickel ...business-humanrights.org
T2
Labor Violations Indonesia Nickel Sector Exposed - The China-Global ...chinaglobalsouth.com

Related Stories

China rare earth export curbs widen global price gap
21 Jul · 10:21 PM
China's CATL invests in hydropower project
21 Jul · 6:51 AM
Global hunger falls for third year, but climate and trade risks loom
21 Jul · 10:14 AM
China maintains strict fuel export controls amid ongoing Iran conflict
21 Jul · 8:40 AM
India Continues High Russian Oil Imports After U.S. Waiver Expiry
21 Jul · 10:41 AM