HomeEverythingEducation
Equities & FundsCrypto & Digital AssetsAI & TechnologyBusiness & CorporateUS Politics & PolicyGeopolitics & Global RiskMacro, Rates & FXCommodities & EnergyEuropean Politics & MarketsAsia-PacificReal Estate & Property
← All Stories

Lufthansa, rivals clash in London court over patent profits

Created at 7 Jul · 2:05 PM1 source↑ Market-relevant
IN SHORT

Lufthansa Technik and its rivals Astronics, Panasonic, and Safran are back in the London Court of Appeal over a patent dispute concerning high-voltage aircraft power outlets. The airline claims its patent was infringed while active, seeking a higher financial award, while the defendants argue the payout is too high and includes unlawful interest.

✉Newsletter

PiQ Daily

Pick your topics. Get only what matters, on your cadence.

Key Numbers

2017year patent infringement dispute began in London
2018year patent expired
2010year litigation began in Germany
2020year London Patents Court ruled on patent
2022year Court of Appeal upheld ruling
2025year High Court ordered accounting for profits

Who's Involved

Lufthansa Technik
German aircraft maintenance subsidiary alleging patent infringement
Astronics Advanced Electronic Systems
US aircraft manufacturer accused of patent infringement
Panasonic
Japanese company accused of patent infringement
Safran
French company accused of patent infringement
Mr Justice Leech
Judge who established defendants must account for profits
Lufthansa, rivals clash in London court over patent profits

↳ Why This Matters

This ongoing legal dispute highlights the complexities and financial stakes involved in intellectual property battles within the aviation industry, impacting revenue streams and potentially influencing future technological development and licensing agreements.

Key facts

  • Lufthansa Technik is in a London court dispute with Astronics Advanced Electronic Systems, Panasonic, and Safran over patent infringement.
  • The dispute concerns a patent for high-voltage aircraft passenger power outlets, allegedly infringed between 2017 and 2018.
  • Previous court rulings found the patent valid and infringed by the defendants.
  • The current appeal concerns the financial payout and interest awarded to Lufthansa Technik.
  • Lufthansa Technik seeks a higher award, while the defendants argue the award is too high and includes unlawful interest.

Lufthansa Technik, a subsidiary of the Lufthansa Group, is engaged in a legal battle in London's Court of Appeal concerning a patent infringement dispute. The German airline maintenance firm alleges that US-based Astronics Advanced Electronic Systems, Japan's Panasonic, and France's Safran copied its patented technology for high-voltage aircraft passenger power outlets while the patent was active, which expired in 2018. The litigation, which began in Germany in 2010, saw English proceedings commence in 2017. A 2020 ruling by the London Patents Court found the patent valid and infringed, a decision upheld by the Court of Appeal in 2022. In early 2025, Mr Justice Leech determined that the defendants must account to Lufthansa for profits earned, including interest. However, both Lufthansa Technik and the defendant manufacturers are dissatisfied with the High Court's calculation of the financial payout, leading to the current appeal hearing. Lufthansa Technik seeks a larger award, while the defendants contend the payout is excessive, includes unlawful interest, and risks overpayment.

Frequently asked questions

The dispute centers on allegations that Astronics, Panasonic, and Safran infringed Lufthansa Technik's patent for high-voltage aircraft passenger power outlets.

The patent for the high-voltage aircraft passenger power outlets expired in 2018.

The parties are currently in the London Court of Appeal, challenging the High Court's calculation of the financial payout related to the patent infringement.

Lufthansa Technik believes the financial award is too low, while the defendants argue it is too high, includes unlawful interest, and risks overpaying Lufthansa.

What Happens Next

01The Court of Appeal is expected to deliver its judgment on the financial payout.

Get the newsletter.

Pick the topics you actually care about. We'll email when there's news worth your time, on the cadence you choose. Cancel any time from your account.

Cadence

How It Developed

Lufthansa Technik alleged patent infringement by Astronics, Panasonic, and Safran in 2017.
The patent for high-voltage aircraft passenger power outlets expired in 2018.
Lufthansa Technik claimed the technology was copied while the patent was active.
English proceedings began in 2017 against Astronics and Safran, and in 2019 against Panasonic.
The London Patents Court ruled the patent valid and infringed in 2020.
The Court of Appeal upheld the infringement ruling in 2022.
The High Court ordered defendants to account to Lufthansa for profits in early 2025.
Both sides are appealing the High Court's financial payout calculation.

Sources

T1
Lufthansa and aviation rivals clash in London court over power outlet profitsCity AM

Related Stories

Louis Vuitton wins $1.5M trademark case against Chinese tea chain
7 Jul · 10:35 AM
United Airlines must face lawsuit over 'window seats' that lack windows
6 Jul · 8:26 PM
Novartis to acquire London biotech Myricx Bio for up to $1.5bn
6 Jul · 5:25 PM
US Airlines Prioritize Premium Cabins for Profitability
7 Jul · 4:45 AM
EasyJet agrees to £5.5bn takeover bid from US private equity firm Castlelake
6 Jul · 4:45 PM